MaidenMadness
Active Member
not kiddingIron Monster said:MM you must be kidding me
Watching the Hunt For Red October :err:
imo lotr is the most overrated book ever
not kiddingIron Monster said:MM you must be kidding me
Watching the Hunt For Red October :err:
MaidenMadness said:not kidding
imo lotr is the most overrated book ever
the_nomad said:yes and the most read in the world after Bible 8)
You are right :wink: ....I hate star wars :|Iron Monster said:There must be a reason that the book is so popular...The ones of you who don't like LOTR won't like other science-ficiton movies/books I suppose
The ones of you who dislike the LOTR movies, do they dislike starwars then...I think so :err:
just cause a lot of people read some book it doesn't mean its great......the_nomad said:yes and the most read in the world after Bible 8)
MaidenMadness said:just cause a lot of people read some book it doesn't mean its great......
compare it with music. a lot of people listen to britney spears for example. does that mean her music is great?
exactly. thats why i didn't say lotr WAS overrated i said that in my opinion its overratedIron Monster said:Well it means that most people think it's great....
Cyrus said:What he doesn't understand is the amount of work Tolkien put into his work. People think he only wrote The Silmarillion, Hobbit and LoTR. His work in unbelieveable! The detail is amazing!
It's in no way overrated!
I don't care if people don't t like it. That's fair, but to spew out comments like it's overrated, it not based on anything put pure ignorance.
the_nomad said:you're right Cyr. the LOTR is the biggest part of his life and he had totally create a world but the meanings go far than a simple adventure. It's a big social work and people must know that to the beginning, the first idea was a poem for childs :shock:
I missed your post too cyrusIron Monster said:Indeed, I didn't see your IMO, my apologies
what was your businesswicker nomad said:I missed your post too cyrus
I wouldn't say that it is overrated....just bloody long!!.....I can see why people like them, I did enjoy the parts of the film that I did see, but I was shattered...it was when I still had my own business...maybe I'll give them another go :wink:
but I know I hate Star Wars
manic said:what was your business
my mum owned a jewelry business not long ago
wicker nomad said:I missed your post too cyrus
I wouldn't say that it is overrated....just bloody long!!.....I can see why people like them, I did enjoy the parts of the film that I did see, but I was shattered...it was when I still had my own business...maybe I'll give them another go :wink:
but I know I hate Star Wars
:err:the_nomad said:and you stole jewels to buy scanner, phones and consoles
An Off Licencemanic said:what was your business
my mum owned a jewelry business not long ago